I would not with good conscience tell you to purchase or not purchase either of these even though the price seems fair enough.
Ya never know how a pipe like these are going to preform and I certainly wouldn't want you to buy a bad pipe because of what I said.
I seldom buy of eBay anymore, getting to be a nut house of no sense bidders. I would try retailers on the internet, shop, shop and shop
till you can get the idea of who's high and who's not, then pick out a pipe from a well known maker. Many places have a layaway plan also,
I know I use it quit often. So do your research and shop around, it'll pay in the end.
Oh, and I'm not talking about brand new pipes, many retailers in pipes sell Estates also and that's what I buy.
I think to date I've only bought 3 new pipes in 15 years or more.