Well I met Todd yesterday at the Reno pipe show and held that very pipe (and discussed it's merits with Marty Pulvers who is always a hoot to talk with). The pipe is pretty impressive and Todd is a very, very friendly and articulate fellow. At one point late in the show another attendee and I walked over to the row of tables where Todd, Brad Pohlman and Jeff Gracik were all sitting and I (being the instigator that I am) started asking these guys why a carver would choose either an $80 piece of briar or a $20 piece of briar when the hoped outcome is the same - a highly figured pipe. It was a most interesting conversation to say the least, with all three gentlemen sharing opinions and insights. Todd told his story of being with Mimmo in Italy and seeing the whole process of briar harvesting and cutting. He explained that you're paying for the cutters expertise in preparing and sorting and how this just increases your likelihood of success. The fact that a well trained eye can present you with the briar that should produce the results you desire. He also told a few little secret truths about briar and it showed how a lot of people have misguided notions about what they're smoking. The gentleman was a wealth of knowledge and shared it freely.
What was most interesting was that all three of these guys, very talented and respected carvers, were very open to discussing their opinions and sharing their knowledge and even going so far as to say "but this is only how I like to do it and I'm certainly not saying it's the right way". Their attitude and the beauty of their work was most impressive, and the fact that they were willing to share it with a basically destitute bum like myself who couldn't afford their pipes anyhow only proves that they're interest is not just in selling high grade pipes but in perpetuating the enthusiasm for fine pipes as best they can. Guys like these are a blessing to pipe enthusiasts and I take my hat off to them.