What Are Your Top Ten Tobaccos?

[Sturdy Papa 359]

Hello BoB,

I‘ve been a little under the weather the past five days, so I decided to put together an actual list of my top ten tobaccos. The list ranking rotates a bit, but the names pretty much stay the same. Look forward to seeing everyone’s top ten. Have a blessed day!

1. Watch City Cigar Flake #558
2. Three Nuns
3. Watch City Cigar Waltham Broken Cake
4. Dan Salty Dogs
5. Peterson 3P’s
6. Rattray’s Marlin Flake
7. Sutliff’s Match Ready Rubbed
8. Stokkebye’s Luxury Navy Flake & Luxury Twist Flake 50/50
9. Stokkebye’s Cube Cut Burley
10. Solani 660 Silver Flake

 

[Ol'Dawg]

1. F&T Cut VA Plug (When available, hard to find)
Black Jack
3. Stok. Lux. Bullseye
Lux Twist
#702 Burley
#701 Va.
7. Ham. Veermaster
8. Vauen Va. #14
9. Pete. University
10. SWR Regular
That's all....

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

1. F&T Cut VA Plug (When available, hard to find)
Black Jack
3. Stok. Lux. Bullseye
Lux Twist
#702 Burley
#701 Va.
7. Ham. Veermaster
8. Vauen Va. #14
9. Pete. University
10. SWR Regular
That's all....

FYI...F&T Blended (VA) Cut Plug and Black Jack are available at Boswell’s.

 

[Ol'Dawg]

Thanks! Boswell has a lot of pipes and tobacco plus they had really helpful employees! I have stopped twice at the Chambersburg, PA during a hunting trip right across a motel that allow dogs. (New avatar shows my dog trying to ride my tractor)

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

Thanks! Boswell has a lot of pipes and tobacco plus they had really helpful employees! I have stopped twice at the Chambersburg, PA during a hunting trip right across a motel that allow dogs. (New avatar shows my dog trying to ride my tractor)

German Shorthaired Pointer?

 

[Ol'Dawg]

"Griff" Wirehaired Pointing Griffon Really great for close hunting birds like grouse, woodcock and quail.

 

[Ranger107]

Mine rotate as well but here goes.
1 my own Urban Cowboy
2 Hobbits Weed
3 Carter Hall
4 CS Rivendell
5 CS Choctaw
6 Arango Balkan Supreme
7 CS Shepherds Pie
8 Rattrays Red Raparee
9 Frog Morton OTT
10 CS Figgy Pudding

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

Mine rotate as well but here goes.
1 my own Urban Cowboy
2 Hobbits Weed
3 Carter Hall
4 CS Rivendell
5 CS Choctaw
6 Arango Balkan Supreme
7 CS Shepherds Pie
8 Rattrays Red Raparee
9 Frog Morton OTT
10 CS Figgy Pudding

Ranger, Thanks. We only have three lists so far, but you can already see different taste patterns. This might get interesting. Give Augie a biscuit for me.

 

[DrT999]

In no particular order and still (I think) in production:
St Bruno Flake
Irish Flake/Rattray's Sterling Flake
Grasmere Flake (if it's ever available in the US again)
GH Brown Flake Unscented & Scented
GH Scotch Flake
GH Louisiana Flake
Royal Yacht
Salty Dogs

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

In no particular order and still (I think) in production:
St Bruno Flake
Irish Flake/Rattray's Sterling Flake
Grasmere Flake (if it's ever available in the US again)
GH Brown Flake Unscented & Scented
GH Scotch Flake
GH Louisiana Flake
Royal Yacht
Salty Dogs

Thanks for joining in Mr./Dr. Moderator.

 

[Corncobcon]

And my top 10 are...

Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

And my top 10 are...

Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall
Carter Hall

Corncobcon,

Now that’s a man who knows what he likes! Although Carter Hall isn’t on my Top 10, it holds a special place with me. My Uncle Dana smoked CH and he was a major influence. Also, excellent tobacco to re-set the taste meter. Thanks for participating.

BoB...Could you imagine how much money we could save if we all just liked one tobacco???

 

[nksmith119]

Royal Yacht, Old Gowrie, MM 965, Irish Flake, University Flake, Hal O The Wynd, GLP Westminister, Escudo, SG Full Virginia Flake, Stonehaven

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

Royal Yacht, Old Gowrie, MM 965, Irish Flake, University Flake, Hal O The Wynd, GLP Westminister, Escudo, SG Full Virginia Flake, Stonehaven

Mostly Virginia, Virginia/Perique, and Virginia/Burley. Nice!

 

[nksmith119]

Mostly Virginia, Virginia/Perique, and Virginia/Burley. Nice!

All roads lead to Virginia

 

[Pipe'n Prof]

Here’s my ten (excluding unobtanium and limited edition stuff).

1. Haddo’s Delight
2. Bayou Morning
3. Escudo
4. Night Train
5. UHLE’s Hunt Club
6. Bayou Night
7. St James Flake
8. Gas Light
9. Luxury Twist Flake
10. Kajun Kake

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

Here’s my ten (excluding unobtanium and limited edition stuff).

1. Haddo’s Delight
2. Bayou Morning
3. Escudo
4. Night Train
5. UHLE’s Hunt Club
6. Bayou Night
7. St James Flake
8. Gas Light
9. Luxury Twist Flake
10. Kajun Kake

Another Virginia/Perique fan...with one nice change of pace (Luxury Twist).

 

[Gusto]

Thank you Pipe 'n Prof for reminding me to open an 8 oz tin of Haddo's from Jan 2007.

 

[davedyer]

Haddo's Delight
GLP Westminster
Orlik Golden Slice
Hal O' the Wynd
Red Rapparee
Presbyterian
Old Gowrie
Skiff Mixture
Solani Aged Burley Flake
GLP Union Square

 

[Sturdy Papa 359]

Haddo's Delight
GLP Westminster
Orlik Golden Slice
Hal O' the Wynd
Red Rapparee
Presbyterian
Old Gowrie
Skiff Mixture
Solani Aged Burley Flake
GLP Union Square

Little bit of everything on that A-List. Nice variety.