Recommendations Please....

Brothers of Briar

Help Support Brothers of Briar:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Mar 11, 2025
Messages
10
Reaction score
13
Location
Montana
58 year old from Montana. I farm cattle by day and hunt and fly fish in any spare time I get.
Decided I'd like to start pipe smoking for relaxation and contemplation. Grandfather and Uncle both smoked pipes when fly fishing.
I'd welcome and appreciate your advice on a pipe ( I like Canadian or lumberman) shape and a straight shaft to start. Budget $125 ish, and Briar . Tobacco recommendations as well.

Thank you all , much appreciated.
 
58 year old from Montana. I farm cattle by day and hunt and fly fish in any spare time I get.
Decided I'd like to start pipe smoking for relaxation and contemplation. Grandfather and Uncle both smoked pipes when fly fishing.
I'd welcome and appreciate your advice on a pipe ( I like Canadian or lumberman) shape and a straight shaft to start. Budget $125 ish, and Briar . Tobacco recommendations as well.

Thank you all , much appreciated.
Get a cob and some cowboy coffee from Country Squire.
 
I agree with Alpha that a good place to start is a cob, clean smoking, inexpensive and disposable - all characteristics that favour an initiate. I would also recommend familiarizing yourself with non-aromatic blends. Become familiar with families of tobacco first, Virginias, Burleys, Latakias, and Orientals without additional flavouring. Alpha recommended some excellent youtube videos from AROMATIX that are well-tailored to beginning this hobby, I found them useful even having smoked a pipe for 35 years. Estate pipes from a reputable shop are also a good way to get a good pipe at less expense.
 
I have a farm so I'm going to assume you're kinda handy. I just started smoking a pipe last year. I bought a couple Savinelli starter pipes as new pipes and bought other new ones after I had more experience. However, I found estate pipes to be a better way to try out different shapes and sizes. They're easy to refurbish with minimal tools. I have over 100 pipes already after a year. A couple of them are from 1900-1920 time frames and that history makes it more fun for me.
It sounds like you want to smoke and do things at the same time. Find a size and shape you can clench without snapping your neck. I agree with cobs as a good place to start. I have two as work pipes and they get wet, dirty, dropped etc.
They smoke great.
 
Not so much on the pipe shape, but if you will clench the stem bit between your teeth, I find vulcanite vs acrylic stems are easier on your teeth. Clenching will mar them up a bit, so be aware if you care. Like others have said, a cob from Missouri meerschaum is a good start, as they have a type of plastic stem that is tough enough but cheap to replace. They offer extras on their website. For a tobacco, maybe a codger blend like Prince Albert, Velvet, ot Granger would work. Hope you get a good start and enjoy. Check out topics to avoid tongue bite, and how to do the breath way of smoking.Muttonchop piper on YT has good videos on this.
https://www.smokingpipes.com/smokin...moking-flavor-and-comfort-with-breath-smoking
 
Since it sounds like you're committed to making it work and will have plenty of opportunities to get the hang of it I would go with your first instinct and skip the cob (for now). The most important aspects of a pipe is that it has a comfortable bit and a good draw for you, a new briar from a popular brand is your best bet for finding that out the gate.
I agree entirely with @Swede sage advice concerning stem material, Acrylic(plastic) stems are too hard and slick to clench comfortably and I only smoke pipes with Vulcanite(rubber) stems.

Take a grain of salt because this is only my opinion and pipe smoking is all about personal preference so I will just tell you what I think would have helped me, If I had to start smoking a pipe all over again.

I would take your pipe budget and get a few cheaper pipes, one base model offered by Peterson, Savinelli and a couple unsmoked estate(NOS) pipes off eBay, depending on the brand they are better quality for much cheaper than current production pipes look for Yello-Bole, Medico, Dr.Grabow, Kaywoodie, Willard. Look at the dimensions when buying any pipe, a good average sized straight pipe is going to be at least |5.34" Overall length| |.75" Bowl Diameter| |1.5"+ Bowl Depth|.

For tobacco I would want to get a few old-school blends that have stood the test of time and then one blend that highlights each of the 5 "types" of tobacco leaf: Virginia, Burley, Cavendish, Latakia, Orientals, in order to develop a basic understanding of what kinds of tobacco I like.
I would start with: a pouch of Sir Walter Raleigh regular, Captain Black original, Half and Half, 2oz bulk samples of Peter Stokebye PS 400 Luxury Navy Flake, PS 17 English Luxury, Lane Limited BL/WB, Cornell and Diehl Virginia Gentleman, Haunted Bookshop and a tin of Orlik Golden Slices.

You need more pipe cleaners than you think starting out, white elephant brand are my favorite because of how stiff they are and keep a couple "czech" tools around because they run away on their own.

Good luck and I hope you enjoy the hobby!
 
Since it sounds like you're committed to making it work and will have plenty of opportunities to get the hang of it I would go with your first instinct and skip the cob (for now). The most important aspects of a pipe is that it has a comfortable bit and a good draw for you, a new briar from a popular brand is your best bet for finding that out the gate.
I agree entirely with @Swede sage advice concerning stem material, Acrylic(plastic) stems are too hard and slick to clench comfortably and I only smoke pipes with Vulcanite(rubber) stems.

Take a grain of salt because this is only my opinion and pipe smoking is all about personal preference so I will just tell you what I think would have helped me, If I had to start smoking a pipe all over again.

I would take your pipe budget and get a few cheaper pipes, one base model offered by Peterson, Savinelli and a couple unsmoked estate(NOS) pipes off eBay, depending on the brand they are better quality for much cheaper than current production pipes look for Yello-Bole, Medico, Dr.Grabow, Kaywoodie, Willard. Look at the dimensions when buying any pipe, a good average sized straight pipe is going to be at least |5.34" Overall length| |.75" Bowl Diameter| |1.5"+ Bowl Depth|.

For tobacco I would want to get a few old-school blends that have stood the test of time and then one blend that highlights each of the 5 "types" of tobacco leaf: Virginia, Burley, Cavendish, Latakia, Orientals, in order to develop a basic understanding of what kinds of tobacco I like.
I would start with: a pouch of Sir Walter Raleigh regular, Captain Black original, Half and Half, 2oz bulk samples of Peter Stokebye PS 400 Luxury Navy Flake, PS 17 English Luxury, Lane Limited BL/WB, Cornell and Diehl Virginia Gentleman, Haunted Bookshop and a tin of Orlik Golden Slices.

You need more pipe cleaners than you think starting out, white elephant brand are my favorite because of how stiff they are and keep a couple "czech" tools around because they run away on their own.

Good luck and I hope you enjoy the hobby!
Thank you kindly for your great input. Much appreciated!!! 👍
 


Write your reply...

Latest posts

Top