Hey Brother Piet,
When and if I smoke an aro, I always go for Peterson. My Christmas 2010 hasn't made it here yet but I have smoked a bit of the Christmas 2009. You are right, the tins are cool which is one of the reasons I bought it. The other being I thought the alpha female might tolerate it after I read the description. I have not smoked any in a while but I did not find it a bad smoke. The tin aroma is great, kind of a spicy vanilla and some apple and that is the way it smells while smoked. I gave some to one of my mechanics for Christmas and I waffed it while he was smoking. I found for myself that smoking it slow seemed to bring out more of the flavorings and it didn't bite me at all. Having said that, the Peterson aro's seem to agree with me more than any others. This is certainly an aro and I am no tobacco reviewer but I know what I like and found it pretty good. Will let you know on the 2010 offering. I think it is worth a shot, but I'd try it for the cool tin. This probably hasn't helped you at all but thats my take on it.