Sorry for dredging up an old thread, especially for my first post, I hate to be "that guy" but I actually joined to comment on this thread. I have been lurking for a while and planned on joining, but when I ran across this thread today I had to post because
I was actually the person to buy that pipe. Yup, that was me.
I had been reading up on refurbishing old pipes to bring back the luster to some of my old pipes, and then after reading and practicing on some of my pipes I got bit by the bug. This pipe was my first that I bought specifically to fix up.
They do say in the auction that it probably isn't the original mouthpiece. I believe it- the thing is very thin with a very narrow draw hole (this is my fourth Pete, and second "System" pipe, so I know it isn't just what the P-lip is like). I thought about bending it some more, but I don't want to risk closing it off any more. The seller tried to be very upfront and I give them points in that they have in the ad that it was very tight and they didn't try to remove it- they emailed me to tell me it was stuck to give me a chance to back out (I didn't, and it took less than 5 minutes to work it off the pipe- cleaning with an alcohol dampened pipe cleaner loosened the gunk that had it stuck).
However, it was definitely in worse shape than the pictures would have you think. The mouthpiece was very green and brown, and the p-lip was a little damaged (like it was partially filed on one side). The "silver" band was much more stained than it appeared in the photos- and despite the description calling it a silver band, it is nickel (I thought I was getting a great deal spending $40 with shipping on a Pete with a sterling silver band, turns out I only got an OK deal overall, and not great considering the condition). Oh well, I bought it to fix up.
It has been a lot of work, but the bowl looks good. The nickel band came off while polishing it so I do need to glue it back on. No matter how much work I do, the mouthpiece still looks pretty bad, even if it was perfectly shiny black it would still look bad (so I haven't bothered with sanding and doing the work to make it perfectly shiny).
I haven't smoked it yet so I don't know how it will smoke. Hopefully it will smoke well, I am actually giving it away to a guy on a pipe and cigar forum who is new to pipe smoking. However, I have suggested to him to send it back to Peterson to get a correct mouthpiece fitted and not judge it based on the one on it.