This is an old review, but it still holds true for me. If I were writing it now, I would tone down the perfervid prose a bit, but I still hold the main points.
Begin Text:
Now for the umpteenth time I've been able to confirm that the MacBaren "macbitey" reputation remains and will remain a complete mystery to me. I do know that many smokers complain that MacB blends bite a lot. This widespread reputation represents the puzzlingest experience I've ever had in the pipe world. Why? Because they do not bite me; I find them all soothing and even curative: Navy Flake, Club Blend, Scottish Mixture. And now, Dark Twist Roll Cake. Body chemistry - it has to be body chemistry. Or I don't know what.
I've found my first tin of DTRC to contain excellent tobacco - excellent. An inspired and transcendent blend. Muted and subtle but rich: the quality and sublime flavor and sidestream of this blend remains sedate yet persistent and commanding throughout the smoke. Smokes at a low level, but you're not supposed to puff just because it doesn't send out volumes of thick smoke; just let it come along in little slow sips. Just nurse, it will respond - do not resuscitate with brutal EPR methods. As with all other tobaccos, I do not puff away seeking a nic hit that is not there. In the MacBarens I've tried that nic hit is just not there and was not supposed to be. I smoked a bowl last night and still retain in memory the subtle mercies of the flavor and aroma that it delivers - in unspectacular yet indelible manner. This almost Proustian, lingering recall of its qualities may explain why those of us that love this blend "feel" the need to reach for a tin, without consciously knowing why. And what an easy pleasure to fill and to keep lit.