McClelland Dark Star

Brothers of Briar

Help Support Brothers of Briar:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
#2035 has some of the strongest, lingering odor of maybe any tobacco I've ever smoked. I dare say even more so than the likes of Nightcap. Escudo might be close. Hours and hours later, it borders on being too much. That much later in the day when I smell it again (on my coat collar or freshly dampened beard), my senses seem like they have to re-register the odor in order for me to appreciate it. I get a split second when it is almost sickening, but that second split second is a pleasant, though pungent, aroma.

I laughed at the idea on Tobacco Reviews that it is "tolerable". I feel this might be a grade more offensive than that.
 
Kap, great review! Ever the knowledgeable smoker, it was very interesting to read how you conquered the Star. I smoked a tin as a pipe youngster, and it conquered me.

Buttressed by your review, maybe I'll get another tin.
 
I've purchased a 100 gram tin earlier this year of Dark Star from 1995, and a 50 from 2001.
I can't wait to experience all the hubub!
 
Ok, I´ve been working on of a tin of Dark Star this week.

It has the (in?)famous McClelland tin note for sure. I don´t want to dwell on that- it is what it is. I detect a little dried fruity smell as well. It´s pretty moist and IMHO is best left sitting with the tin open for a while.

Indeed, it requires patience to get ahold of what to do with it. Packing and keeping lit is a challenge. Letting it dry a little has helped a lot and I have experimented with folding, cubing, and rubbing out. Rubbing it out is quite difficult as it tends to break into smaller flakes before coming apart at the seams. My most successful smokes have been with cubing or folding.

It takes me several lights to get this one going. Patience is the thing. Once it gets going it has a surprisingly sweet flavor- but that will disappear if you puff it too hard. As I get into the bowl I notice a raisiny, or currant-y note, but only apparent at low temperature. This sweetness intensifies as I get mid bowl and it will take slightly more aggressive puffing at this pont. It is a little reminiscent of Peterson´s 3P´s with the fruitiness, though not as defined. The currant flavor really comes out in toward the bottom of the bowl. As Kap said, a molasses, smokier type of flavor is apparent at this point. I didn´t notice huge shifts in the dominant fruity flavor throughout the bowl. The main "note" was constant throughout, only to be enhanced by a more aged smokier version of that at the end.

All in all a good, flavorful smoke, if you have the time and the patience. It is not a stuff and puff all day kind of tobacco as time and diligence really are necessary to get the most of it. I will concur with Kap that it goes well with a hot beverage (coffee) rather than a cool one.

I´m sure I´ll notice more as I get to know this blend, but this are my preliminary thoughts.



:cat:
 
I like McClelland Dark Star, except that it's like trying to get asbestos to burn. Once it finally gets sparked up: YUM!
 
I've had no trouble keeping 2035 burning, and I just purchased a fresh batch (as in just put together at the blenders) and still had no problem lighting it and enjoying a long smoke without a re-light.

are you folks not rubbing it out at all?
 
I've been working on a long-forgotten tin I found this week, tinned '05, open prolly since '07. Dried and brittle, smelling of acetic and lactic acids, it would normally have been tossed. That tragedy was averted after reading your posts. When cut to bark-mulch (1/16") with a scissors (thank you for that), and packed moderately in an ancient Kaywoodie, it gets in the zone at second light and refuses to yield for a damn fine half hour. Never noticed it's fine signature aroma on my facial hair, but it does stick to my clothes, reminding me to pack up again. One fine weed.
 
talrmn35":ujrc7dv9 said:
Amen to that! It's good to be a man!
One of the about 1,000 reasons it's good. Maybe I'll write the book "A Thousand Reasons It's Good To Be a Man".

That'll PO about 52% of the population. Which'll take care of those other than the ten or twenty I've personally PO'd. :lol:
 
I really like Dark Star, and ordered a tin of Royal Cajun Ebony to compare.

I am on the verge of ordering another tin of Dark Star, but I'm wondering if I should go for Blackwoods instead. Is Blackwoods Dark Star mixed with mature Red Va? That sounds very appealing to me.
 
Ground up a tin of Dark Star a while ago and let it sit for a month. Much better, stays lit, earthy and full.
 

Latest posts

Top