I have a very old, (4 digit shape number), Kaywoodie Canadian. It smokes like a dream. I try not to smoke it much though, because, well, it's old and I want it to last until I am, then I don't care.... so... I recentlly surcumbed to buying a lesser expenisve GBD Premier Canadian/Lovat. It's new, and my big dilema is whether to smoke it, save it, or sell it. (It really was an impusle buy.) I have an older GBD Virgin Lovat that is one of my favorite pipes. It has a small crack at the end of the shank, so I had it reparied with a band, and now it is for smoking and only smoking... and I'm glad of it, because it is one of my best pipes. I got it for next to nothing because it needed the repair... money very well spent. I am of the school that the longer shank makes a difference in the quality of the smoke. Just my opinion. I also have an older Kaywoodie Lovat with a cut off stinger... that pipe smokes like a chiminey... clouds of cool smoke... fun pipe too.